Competitor Intelligence Report
Every complaint is a product gap. Every 1-star review is a feature request. Every frustrated user is a customer waiting to switch. We pulled thousands of real complaints and clustered them so you can see exactly where Workday is bleeding — and what you could build to take their customers.
Users describe Workday as a steaming pile of burnt garbage with obtuse, non-intuitive navigation requiring multiple clicks for simple tasks.
"Workday is a steaming pile of burnt garbage. I've never come across software so obtusely non-intuitive"
"navigation can be complex, requiring multiple clicks for simple tasks"
The system has a noticeable learning curve especially for employees who do not use it often, with no clear guidance on what it can do.
"The system can also have a noticeable learning curve, especially for employees who don't use it often"
"the system can be a bit too simple, there's not a ton of clear guidance on what the system can do, users would have to explore and figure it out themselves"
Workday is outdated software that grew too quickly, making it fundamentally hard to make user-friendly.
"The problem is that workday is an outdated, confusing, piece of software that grew too quickly and so it's hard to make it user-friendly"
"Poor Interface Design (38 mentions)"
The loading spinner appears frequently when switching between modules, especially during payroll cutoffs and performance review cycles.
"The web interface can sometimes be sluggish and heavy to load, especially during peak usage times like payroll cutoffs or performance review cycles"
"The 'loading' spinner appears frequently when switching between modules"
Features feel overly rigid and limited in customization, making it harder to tailor processes to specific business needs.
"Limited Customization (31 mentions)"
"some features feel overly rigid or limited in customization, making it harder to tailor processes to specific business needs"
Workday is too expensive for smaller companies, pricing out the mid-market entirely.
"Workday is an expensive platform, so it may not be a good fit for smaller companies"
Implementations are challenging projects that flow over into production, requiring significant time investment explaining processes to the product team.
"Definitely work with your product team and explain why you do a certain process and what you are hoping to achieve. It takes a lot of time"
"Implementations of the system can be challenging for organizations to handle and typically are difficult projects, resulting in work that flows over to Production"
If you are not given the correct security level you simply cannot do your job, creating bottlenecks across HR operations.
"Security! Although it's a good thing that people can have different security levels and their access can be limited, sometimes, working in HR, if you aren't given the correct security you simply can't do your job"
"in Workday Learning, you need Learning Admin access to manage employees' learning, but if you're not granted that access, you end up having to rely on the internal Workday/HRIS team"
Executive Summary
Workday is universally described as unintuitive and outdated by the employees forced to use it — "steaming pile of burnt garbage" is not an outlier opinion. The implementation failure rate and the ongoing navigation complexity mean organisations pay twice: once for licensing and again for consultants and IT time. A modern HCM platform built around intuitive navigation, fast implementations, and accessible security controls would immediately resonate with the HR professionals Workday has consistently failed. The mid-market in particular is priced out and underserved.
Every market has a winner. Underbelly shows you exactly where that winner is losing. Run a live analysis on any competitor and see their weak spots in minutes.
Expose Workday's Weak Spots →More competitor intelligence: